王砾, 杨佩佩, 郑煜轩, 代昀昊. 职工董事与民营企业劳动诉讼:“名副其实”抑或“形同虚设”?J. 证券市场导报, 2026, (5): 3-13, 46.
引用本文: 王砾, 杨佩佩, 郑煜轩, 代昀昊. 职工董事与民营企业劳动诉讼:“名副其实”抑或“形同虚设”?J. 证券市场导报, 2026, (5): 3-13, 46.
Wang Li, Yang Peipei, Zheng Yuxuan, Dai Yunhao. Employee Directors and Labor Litigation in Private Enterprises: "Substantive Function" or "Nominal Existence"?J. Securities Market Herald, 2026, (5): 3-13, 46.
Citation: Wang Li, Yang Peipei, Zheng Yuxuan, Dai Yunhao. Employee Directors and Labor Litigation in Private Enterprises: "Substantive Function" or "Nominal Existence"?J. Securities Market Herald, 2026, (5): 3-13, 46.

职工董事与民营企业劳动诉讼:“名副其实”抑或“形同虚设”?

Employee Directors and Labor Litigation in Private Enterprises: "Substantive Function" or "Nominal Existence"?

  • 摘要: 近年来,我国劳动争议案件数量持续增加,民营企业劳动关系问题是劳资矛盾的重中之重。当前,国有企业通常强制设立职工董事,民营企业自愿设立职工董事,民企职工董事能否维护劳动者权益、缓和劳资冲突亟需深入研究。本文以沪深A股民营上市公司为样本,基于裁判文书数据,研究发现职工董事设立显著减少了民营企业劳动诉讼,该结论在经过一系列稳健性检验后依然成立。作用机制一是参与薪酬与考核委员会,提升薪酬制度的客观性与合理性,有效抑制高管过高薪酬,显著提升薪酬公平性,降低因分配失衡引发劳动争议的可能;二是参与重大决策和监督决策执行,约束管理层的机会主义行为,降低代理成本,增强员工的认同感和信任度,减少因治理问题引发的劳动纠纷。异质性检验表明,在用工成本较高、员工信任度较低、劳动密集度较高的企业,以及竞争激烈行业、失业率较高地区、法律环境薄弱地区的企业中,职工董事的治理效果更明显。本文为完善我国职工董事制度、构建和谐劳资关系、推动民营企业高质量发展提供了有益参考。

     

    Abstract: In recent years, the number of labor dispute cases in China has continued to increase, and the issue of labor relations in private enterprises is the most critical problem in labor-management conflicts. At present, state-owned enterprises are mandatorily required to establish employee director positions, private enterprises adopt them voluntarily. Whether employee directors in private enterprises can protect workers' rights and alleviate labor-management conflicts warrants in-depth investigation. Using private listed companies on Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share markets as samples and based on judicial verdict data, this study finds that the establishment of employee directors significantly reduces labor litigation in private enterprises, a conclusion that remains robust after a series of robustness checks. The mechanisms operate through: First, participation in compensation and assessment committees enhances the objectivity and rationality of compensation systems, effectively restrains excessive executive compensation, significantly improves compensation equity, and reduces the likelihood of labor disputes arising from distributional imbalances. Second, participation in major decision-making and supervision of decision implementation constrains management's opportunistic behavior, reduces agency costs, enhances employee identification and trust, and decreases labor disputes stemming from governance issues. Heterogeneity tests indicate that the governance effect of employee directors is more pronounced in enterprises with higher labor costs, lower employee trust, and higher labor intensity, as well as in enterprises operating in highly competitive industries, regions with higher unemployment rates, and regions with weaker legal environments. This study provides valuable reference for improving China's employee director system, constructing harmonious labor-management relations, and promoting high-quality development of private enterprises.

     

/

返回文章
返回